‘Fights Are Frequent, Drunkenness Flourishes, Vice Abounds’

Discover how Mary Leslie’s 1878 novel, The Cromaboo Mail Carrier, sparked outrage and controversy in Erin, Ontario.

November 19, 2026 | | Back Story

Not surprisingly, Erin residents were outraged by Mary Leslie’s less-than-favourable portrayal of the village in her 1878 novel, The Cromaboo Mail Carrier. After all, as her story unfolded, few could fail to recognize that “Cromaboo” was a thinly disguised version of their hometown.

The book’s opening paragraph left no doubt about Mary’s opinion. Describing Cromaboo as the “most blackguard village in Canada,” she wrote, “It consists of seven taverns, six churches, and about one hundred shabby frame houses …. Fights are frequent, drunkenness flourishes, vice abounds; more tobacco is smoked there than in any village of the same size in the Dominion; swearing is so common that it passes unnoticed, and there is an illegitimate child in nearly every house … and the people think it no sin.”

Mary Leslie, 1863; Mary Leslie Fonds, F 675, B410543; Archives Of Ontario

Though the accuracy of Mary’s critique of 19th-century Erin is debatable, she would certainly have been familiar with the stage coach driven by the handsome – and virtuous – young man who is the “mail carrier” of the book’s title. The Leslie family home, where Mary lived much of her life, was located east of Guelph on the Gravel Road, now Wellington Road 124. So the Guelph-Erin stage, which carried mail and passengers back and forth, would have been a regular sight (see “Jolting Along the Gravel Road,” summer 2024).

So incensed were Erin residents that the book’s Guelph-based publisher withdrew the novel from circulation. This was a blow to Mary’s literary ambitions – and her pocketbook, for she had hoped sales of the book would recoup the money she had scraped together to finance its publication. It also put paid to her plan to publish a sequel.

  • Story Continues Below Advertisements
  • Despite this setback, Mary remained determined to make a living as a writer. Though she never published another novel, she continued to write for magazines and published several books.

    A postscript: The Cromaboo Mail Carrier was first published under the pen name James Thomas Jones. In 2016, nearly 140 years later, Vocamus Editions, a Guelph-based publisher, reissued the book. The name on the cover? Mary Leslie.

    About the Author

    More by Dyanne Rivers

    Related Recipes

    prohibition ontario

    A Good Friday Donnybrook Fair

    Mar 14, 2026 | Dyanne Rivers | Back Story

    Prohibition laws of the late 1800s often led to hotels functioning as underground drinking holes that even local constables had trouble breaking up.

    Mary Brett, Farmerette

    Sep 8, 2023 | Dyanne Rivers | Back Story

    As World War II raged in 1943, dozens of Shelburne High School students traded in their textbooks for farmers’ tools to support the war efforts.

    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    By posting a comment you agree that IN THE HILLS magazine has the legal right to publish, edit or delete all comments for use both online or in print. You also agree that you bear sole legal responsibility for your comments, and that you will hold IN THE HILLS harmless from the legal consequences of your comment, including libel, copyright infringement and any other legal claims. Any comments posted on this site are NOT the opinion of IN THE HILLS magazine. Personal attacks, offensive language and unsubstantiated allegations are not allowed. Please report inappropriate comments to vjones@inthehills.ca.

    For security, use of CloudFlare's Turnstile service is required which is subject to the CloudFlare Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.