The Caledon Horse that Could

With typical Canadian modesty, Rumble attributes the lion’s share of the credit for his achievement to his mount, a big-boned gelding named Cilroy.

September 11, 2014 | | Leisure

Cilroy, the Cheltenham-born horse John Rumble rode to a medal in the 1956 Olympics.

Cilroy, the Cheltenham-born horse John Rumble rode to a medal in the 1956 Olympics.

The equestrian sport of eventing has deep roots in Caledon. They were put down 58 years ago when John Rumble brought home a team bronze medal from the 1956 Olympic Games, when the equestrian events took place in Stockholm. With typical Canadian modesty, Rumble attributes the lion’s share of the credit for his achievement to his mount, a big-boned gelding named Cilroy (pronounced “Kilroy”), who was born on a farm near Cheltenham.

Cilroy’s name might have disappeared in the mists of time – if it hadn’t been immortalized in Barbara May’s 1959 book, The Five Circles. Selling 6,000 copies, the book qualified as a Canadian bestseller at the time, and though it is long out of print, a generation of young riders, myself among them, were inspired by the story of this dark bay horse.

Cilroy was a 17.2-hand warmblood cross between a coach horse and a thoroughbred. At the time only thoroughbreds, with their superior stamina, were considered suitable for the considerable endurance required by eventing.

“No one thought he would be going to the Olympics,” says Rumble. Least of all Rumble himself, who accepted owner Harold Crang’s offer of Cilroy only after his own horse broke down a few months before the Games. “Harold stepped up and offered to help,” says Rumble. “Cilroy was basically a hunter who had also been well trained in dressage by Harold’s stable manager, Fred Hughes, who had formed a tremendously close bond with him. But he had never jumped in a horse show.”

Combined with saddle and bridle, the six-foot-two Rumble weighed in at 20 pounds more than the 165-pound minimum set for competitors. Even carrying a much heavier load than most other horses, Cilroy was one of only 12 horses out of a field of 57 to complete a clean round on the cross-country course. It had rained throughout the day before and was still raining on the day of the event, so the course was treacherous, Rumble says.

Of the 19 teams in the competition, just seven, including the Canadians, managed to get all three of their horses through without being eliminated. Sixty-six horse-and-rider falls were recorded. “That’s how people get killed,” Rumble says. In those days a rider who fell could remount and carry on. “Spectators would catch your horse for you and vault you back into the saddle,” he says. Today, a fall means automatic elimination.

  • Story Continues Below Advertisements
  • But eventing was a different sport back then. Today, eventing dressage has increased in both degree of difficulty and overall importance in the three trials that make up the three-day event. Stadium jumping, too, is more difficult than it used to be. But the cross-country portion has undergone the biggest transformation.

    In Rumble’s day, the cross-country was a gruelling 22-mile endurance test – now known as the long or classic format – performed in four phases: five miles of roads and tracks at a brisk trot and canter; a two-mile traditional steeplechase at a gallop over 12 fences; another 10 miles of roads and tracks at a trot and canter ending with a rest and a veterinary check (in this phase, the rider often dismounted and ran alongside the horse to save its strength); and finally, a 4.8-mile cross-country gallop over 33 obstacles.

    JohnRumble, Cilroy and Trainer

    John Rumble, Cilroy and Trainer

    This monumental challenge to horse and rider originated in 19th-century Europe as a way of identifying the best cavalry officers and horses in preparation for battlefield action. Indeed, until 1948, the sport was restricted to male military officers. The first woman competed in 1964.

    Eventually, the cost and the large venue required for the long format’s first three phases led the International Olympic Committee to consider dropping eventing from the Games altogether. And so, to preserve the sport, today’s short format was adopted after the 2000 Olympics in Sydney. It retained only the final phase of the original sport: an approximately four-mile cross-country gallop over obstacles.

    Rumble, for one, was happy with the change. “It was tremendously challenging and dangerous,” he says. “Three-day eventing, in its traditional format, has been recognized as one of the highest-risk sports in the world.”

    And though spectators at next summer’s Pan American Games can expect to see a much tamer cross-country event than the one Rumble rode in, the course is also much more technical – with tight turns and jump combinations requiring horse and rider to use strategy and intelligence when executing them.

    The Pan Am cross-country course at Will O’Wind Farm in Mono is classified under FEI (Fédération Équestre Internationale) rules as a two-star course. The fences are not as high and the course is less demanding than Olympic four-star courses. This is because, in a sport still dominated by Europeans, many South and Central American countries do not have teams qualified to compete at a three- or four-star level.

    Still, the cross-country portion of the event at Will O’Wind next July 18 promises to be exciting. And Rumble plans to be there. After he returned from Stockholm in 1956 with his bronze medal, his eventing days were over, he says. But the sport remains in his blood.

    Cilroy was exceptional, and his legacy has inspired Rumble to help another rider along the same path. Eighteen years ago he bought a farm in King Township, and he later purchased a four-year-old gelding he named Foxwood High, aka Woody. If all goes well, Woody – ridden by eventing veteran Selena O’Hanlon of Kingston – will represent Canada at the Pan Ams.

    “Foxwood High is great,” says Rumble. But Cilroy will always hold a special place in his heart.

    eventing_JohnRumbleCilroy_water eventing_JohnRumbleCilroy_33 eventing_JohnRumbleCilroy_19
    Combined with saddle and bridle, the six-foot-two Rumble weighed in at 20 pounds more than the 165-pound minimum set for competitors.

    About the Author More by Cecily Ross

    Cecily Ross is an author and freelance writer who lives in Creemore.

    Related Stories

    Riders who pounded across the Will O’Wind course at the observation event this summer: Selena O’Hanlon on Bloomsday. Photo by Ellen Cameron.

    Cross Country at a Gallop

    Sep 11, 2014 | Cecily Ross | Leisure

    For one day next summer, the eyes of the Americas will be on Mono’s Will O’Wind Farm, site of the cross-country phase of the Pan Am Games three-day event.



    1. I was thinking about Cilroy the horse.
      My godmother was Canadian and would send me books to England.
      I remember receiving a book about a horse called Cilroy and about 5 circles.
      I was so pleased find this post and to remember it was a real story I had read.
      I don’t think my mum kept my book but I loved the story.

      I write my own stories now.

      Sue Wickstead from United Kingdom on Aug 23, 2022 at 1:38 pm | Reply

    2. Having just spent the weekend at The Forks with the Rumbles, I am happy to still see this article. John is passionate about Eventing and loves to comment on every ride and rider he watches. He is a wealth of knowledge and a very entertaining gentleman. Canada is lucky to have him in our history books, still sponsoring and still in the stands!

      Anita Leschied on Apr 11, 2016 at 10:43 am | Reply

    3. Three cheers for The Hills to recognize the truly significant achievements of John Rumble and his team so many years ago. History told by those who actually made it is a treasure we should all appreciate. The fundations of Canada’s success in the equestrian sports today was built by the likes of John Rumble. A great sportsman and a gentleman of the highest order. Good luck to the Eventers in the Pan Am 2015.

      gary van bolderen from caledon on Sep 12, 2014 at 9:02 am | Reply

    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    By posting a comment you agree that IN THE HILLS magazine has the legal right to publish, edit or delete all comments for use both online or in print. You also agree that you bear sole legal responsibility for your comments, and that you will hold IN THE HILLS harmless from the legal consequences of your comment, including libel, copyright infringement and any other legal claims. Any comments posted on this site are NOT the opinion of IN THE HILLS magazine. Personal attacks, offensive language and unsubstantiated allegations are not allowed. Please report inappropriate comments to