A Caledon Cottage Reborn

How a Toronto couple transformed a dilapidated house into a year-round sanctuary.

March 26, 2018 | | At Home in the Hills

Not everyone can see the beauty in a neglected bungalow surrounded by lawns and woods that seem ready to swallow it up.

But it was beauty a Toronto advertising executive saw when he clapped eyes on an abandoned, slumping one-and-a-half-storey house for sale on a messy wooded property in 2012. Not even its empty and crumbling swimming pool could break the spell.

The home’s mudroom features exposed brick, a new window, a long wooden bench and a vintage rug. Photo by Nat Caron.

The home’s mudroom features exposed brick, a new window, a long wooden bench and a vintage rug. Photo by Nat Caron.

Instead of feeling a shiver as if he’d stepped into a horror film, his heart was filled with glee by the whole property. It was the same place whose laneway he had peeked up during a bike ride on Forks of the Credit Road years earlier – and never forgotten.

“I thought, ‘This is the house,’” he says. He remembers loving what he saw so much, he worried, “It would never be ours.”

While many buyers would raze the house and start again, he and his partner, an academic, were keen to nurture it back to health. She says when she saw it, she knew, “We will be its custodians,” preserving what they could.

They teamed up with architect Harry Lay to plot its future. Harry is also based in Toronto, but has a long history of working in Headwaters. At first it wasn’t clear how much could be saved, he says, but as they “stripped away the accretions” layered on the building, what was left was a classic Craftsman-style bungalow, a sturdy early 20th-century style known for its low-pitched roofs, deep overhanging eaves and long verandas.

“For them to look at this building and say, ‘We’re going to keep it,’ was a huge leap of faith,” Harry says. “They thought they could hear the building speak to them, and once I had a good look at it and got into it and underneath it, their hunch was absolutely correct.”

A few cautionary adventures and brainstorming design sessions later, the bungalow was on its way to being reborn as a bright, human-scale country home, somehow unpretentious and refined at the same time, and a new anchor in this couple’s personal history.

The soul of the house

After the owners welcome me into their sunny kitchen on a Saturday last fall, he shares a scrapbook of photos while she puts the finishing touches on what she calls a “big country lunch” for a gaggle of family members about to arrive. It stars a roasted pork loin from Caledon’s Heatherlea Farm Shoppe and homemade apple sauce. His mother is visiting and sits with us at a large black pedestal table.

This country lifestyle is relatively fresh to them. Although he had spent years skiing on winter weekends at Caledon Ski Club, neither had owned a weekend chalet or summer cottage before, despite sharing a love of nature you’d expect from two British Columbia natives. In fact, “we loved being in the city on summer weekends and having it all to ourselves.”

The second floor of the home is splendidly bright, thanks to its many unadorned windows. Photo by Nat Caron.

The second floor of the home is splendidly bright, thanks to its many unadorned windows. Photo by Nat Caron.

As a new couple when he spotted the property for sale, they knew diving into the project would be a formidable task. “It was an interesting test,” she says with a smile.

To start, the pair transformed a building on the property that was once a dog kennel into a modest little bunkie. “You can’t make this stuff up. We spent three or four years working like dogs,” she says. Jobs included clearing brush, landscaping the pond and around the house, and starting a vegetable garden. Friends came and helped the determined duo clear away 30 years of garbage before the real renovation began.

When it came to the house, they were interested in Harry’s knack for bringing old places back to life. “We wanted a modern feel, but one that was sympathetic to the soul of the house.”

Once they were down to the brick and stucco core, the trio began meeting on-site to brainstorm how the couple wanted to live in the house and what views to capitalize on. What they came to realize was their predecessors had thought this stuff through for them. The south-facing veranda, for instance, was exactly where it should be. The swimming pool was in just the right spot to catch the last sunlight of a summer day.

“The original house was built by someone who had spent time here,” 
he says.

“There was a logic to it,” she agrees.

To maintain the fresh feel of the newly opened space, they started with clean white walls (Benjamin Moore’s Cloud White, to be exact) and refinished the wooden floors that run seamlessly throughout the main level. The construction team pulled up and stripped the original flooring, adding new wood to fill in gaps and staining it to match. Instead of tearing down the crumbling mantel, the team restored it using a traditional rope-style mortar detail to pull its Ontario fieldstones back together. “Why would you get rid of this?” he says.

The only entirely new space is the kitchen which bumps out to the north and looks like a conservatory from the outside. There are no upper cabinets and the greater part of three walls are all black-framed windows – even behind the six-burner stove.

“The windows were totally important,” he says. “Because it took three years to start the building process, we had time to think about the views, structure and layout.”

While there was plenty of room for a kitchen island, “they didn’t fall back on clichéd patterns,” as Harry puts it. Instead a handsome black oak library table bought on Kijiji beckons visitors to sit and linger.

Elsewhere, the updated space – about 1,400 square feet on the main floor and 900 on the second (with a small bedroom in the basement) – reads as equally spare, without being showroom sterile. In the dining room, for instance, the simple vintage Dutch school chairs around the table are counterpoint to a Victorian sideboard and two huge black and white pieces by American painter and graphic designer Robert Rauschenberg. Around the corner, a large 16th-century oil painting features a little girl pointing toward the kitchen.

The wins aren’t all visual – some are about touch. The deep-red screened porch doors, for example, are sized up to match new high ceilings, but they are lightweight “old slammers,” as Harry calls them, reminiscent of long-ago childhood summers. “Harry was great on details like that,” the owner notes appreciatively.

  • Story Continues Below Advertisements

  • Harry credits the savvy, sensitive local tradespeople as instrumental on that count. Contractor Paul Janssen of JDC Custom Homes in Melancthon headed up the project, which also included Erin cabinetmaker Glenn Nelson who made the sleek kitchen cupboards. “Renovations are ten times harder than new builds, simply for the surgical skill set required to not compromise the building and to add something which heightens the good vibe of the original,” says Harry.

    A new chapter

    The couple remain inspired by the history of the property and are busy layering on their own chapter. Their kids are away at university, but the pair dabble in ski racing at the club, hiking and long-distance cycling, hosting a large group during an annual fall ride.

    athome_1925 athome_0701_30 athome_0554 athome_0531 athome_0510_44 athome_0487_43 athome_0448 athome_0644 athome_0622 athome_0424 athome_0661
    The only addition to the home is a show-stopping new kitchen, with windows on three sides, a vintage rug and a library table instead of an island. Photo by Nat Caron.

    The family who built and owned the 
house for many years gave them a watercolour of it, now displayed in the downstairs powder room. They were also given a 1950s black and white photo of a group of Caledon Ski Club friends posing outside the house on a summer day. They recreated the photo with biking pals last fall, substituting bike helmets and spandex for the ’50s shirtsleeves and pleated pants. “I like the fact the house has been used for decades by people enjoying Caledon,” he says. “We’ve fallen in love with the area.”

    As we finish up an outdoor tour, he stands in the laneway he biked by five years earlier, only now the house before him is all straight lines, fresh stucco and new cedar shakes. On the front lawn though, the original moss-covered stone steps are pitching even more to the right than they did on that long-ago day. For this duo, though, the steps speak of time’s passage and will not be remade.

    “I love the patina,” he says. “I don’t want perfection.”

    About the Author More by Tralee Pearce

    Tralee Pearce is the deputy editor of In The Hills Magazine.

    Related Stories

    Heatherlea’s large new market opened this spring. Photo by Pete Paterson.

    Heatherlea Farm Shoppe

    Jun 20, 2016 | Tralee Pearce | Food

    With its own livestock and in-house butchers, this Caledon farm reinvents traditional food production in a shiny new market.

    Caledon Building & Design, brought skilled trades, organization and a good sense of humour to the work. Photo by Pam Purves.

    An Eco-revival for a Gothic Farmhouse

    Mar 21, 2012 | Pam Purves | At Home in the Hills

    Erica Hyland wanted a “green” renovation for her 1881 Caledon farmhouse. Architect Harry Morison Lay obliged.

    The established trees shield the entrance to the house and provide natural shade where trillium, May apple and wild anemone flourish in the woodland garden.

    A European Manor in the Erin Countryside

    Jun 17, 2014 | Pam Purves | At Home in the Hills

    The established trees shield the entrance to the house and provide natural shade where trillium, May apple and wild anemone flourish in the woodland garden.

    The heritage stone house and its newer counterpart cast serene reflections on the stillness of the upper pond. Photo by Pam Purves.

    A Family Seat

    Sep 16, 2016 | Pam Purves | At Home in the Hills

    A compound of historic buildings and fishing ponds makes an idyllic gathering place for family and friends.

    Crisp and white, Compass House, designed by Toronto architecture firm Superkül, sits on a 200-acre property in the hills of Mulmur. Photo by Ben Rahn / A-Frame Studio.

    A Mulmur Masterpiece by Architecture Firm Superkül

    Mar 19, 2019 | Tralee Pearce | At Home in the Hills

    How a project called Compass House helped one family build roots in Dufferin County – and cemented its two architects’ love of the area.

    The grand Victorian exterior of Sandy and Peter Reeves’ Hillsburgh farmhouse has changed little since it was built in 1876. Photo by Rosemary Hasner / Black Dog Creative Arts.

    At Home with Pond Side Pilates

    Sep 16, 2019 | Tralee Pearce | At Home in the Hills

    How a lush Hillsburgh property warms the souls of its English expat owners – and neighbours looking to get fit.

    Home is Where the Art is

    Jun 20, 2019 | Tralee Pearce | At Home in the Hills

    When entrepreneurs and artists Jocelyn Burke and James Webster renovated Jocelyn’s childhood home in Horning’s Mills, they laid the perfect groundwork for a well-curated life.

    West Coast Modern finds a home in the hills. A private balcony off the master bedroom is ideal for morning coffee. Photo by Pam Purves.

    How West Coast Modern Made it to the Edge of Palgrave

    Mar 20, 2017 | Pam Purves | At Home in the Hills

    Amid farmhouses and Victorian gothic, this sleek West Coast Modern design stands out in style.

    A family finds both continuity with the past and dreams fulfilled in a historic log house in Caledon. Photo by Erin Fitzgibbon.

    Safe Haven in a Log Cabin

    Jun 25, 2020 | Janice Quirt | At Home in the Hills

    A family finds both continuity with the past and dreams fulfilled in a historic log house in Caledon.

    In the uninhibited riot of colour and texture of the dining room, guests can’t help but leave any stuffiness at the door. Photo by Pam Purves.

    The Mad Hatter’s Country Home

    Sep 16, 2017 | Pam Purves | At Home in the Hills

    Ron and Glenn are interior designers by trade – and they’re adventurous. One suspects Alice and the Mad Hatter would feel quite at home here.

    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    By posting a comment you agree that IN THE HILLS magazine has the legal right to publish, edit or delete all comments for use both online or in print. You also agree that you bear sole legal responsibility for your comments, and that you will hold IN THE HILLS harmless from the legal consequences of your comment, including libel, copyright infringement and any other legal claims. Any comments posted on this site are NOT the opinion of IN THE HILLS magazine. Personal attacks, offensive language and unsubstantiated allegations are not allowed. Please report inappropriate comments to vjones@inthehills.ca.